“Do you know of any good resources on the subject of questioning/declining vaginal examination? I’m thinking of vaginal examinations in a number of contexts – well woman exams, vaginal examinations in labour and especially at the end of pregnancy, as women in my area are being told they need to have a vaginal examination in order to assess their cervix for induction and for the purposes of a stretch and sweep. I’m a childbirth educator and I’m looking for some resources to share via email and then discuss with my groups.”
As with all my resource posts, these are just a few of the resources that I’m aware of, and there are many more out there. Please feel free to suggest others and check for relevance before you share any of these, as the content can change without notice!
Well woman exams
In some countries, such as the US, healthy, asymptomatic women have long been advised to have regular pelvic examination (despite being healthy and asymptomatic) as part of an annual so-called ‘well woman’ examination. Many other countries don’t have this recommendation and, instead, pelvic examination is usually offered only if a woman actively seeks medical examination because she is concerned that she may have a problem. Recently, however, this practice has come under question and in Doctors are examining your genitals for no reason, Amanda Hess reports on how several US bodies have changed their recommendations in this area in recent years. Her post might be a useful trigger for discussion with a group.
Vaginal examination in pregnancy
The idea that vaginal examination is useful or necessary during pregnancy is also more common in some countries than others. However, as suggested by the question above, it is becoming more common within the context of earlier induction of labour, which many people do not believe to be an evidence-based practice. Here are a few of my blog posts which might be useful:
Here’s an article called The myth of the vaginal exam at the end of pregnancy. It is written within a US context, so not all of it applies to women in other countries, especially the bit about having vaginal examination early in pregnancy, but it could be a good starting point for discussion.
And Hey Doc, keep your fingers out of my vagina! is another article which might be useful for women in countries where vaginal examination in pregnancy is a more common occurrence, but it also highlights the very important point that vaginal examination is not mandatory, not always necessary and is associated with potential downsides as well as potential benefits.
Vaginal examination in labour
My all-time favourite piece on this topic is Vaginal examinations: a symptom of a cervical-centric birth culture, by midwife Rachel Reed. Rachel has actually referenced and linked to pretty much every other resource and paper that I know of on this topic, so there’s no need for me to share more as her blog post is so extensive and well resourced.
What I will share though, are a couple of pieces on consent which relate to this. Firstly, birthrights has recently published a guide on women’s legal rights during pregnancy and childbirth within the UK, and Rachel Reed has published a useful piece on information-giving and the law within an Australian context.
Finally, while I was writing the post I remembered three great quotes that I wanted to share with you on this. The first two are published quotes, both quoted in the article referenced below:
“Imagine trying to do a vaginal exam on a mother tiger in labour…”
– Sister MorningStar.
“Women have the right to refuse vaginal exams and any procedure being imposed upon us. We have the right to ask questions.”
– Ibu Robin Lim
The third is something that Ina May Gaskin said when we were teaching a workshop together in early 2017. I was so struck by the way she expressed herself when she was talking about how crazy the culture of vaginal examinations has become that I wrote her exact words down:
“For most of time, nobody put their fingers in there. Just imagine … how many people got born without anybody putting their fingers in there?!”
– Ina May Gaskin
If you’d like to stay up-to-date with birth-related research and thinking, make sure you’re subscribed to our free newsletter list, which means you’ll get Sara’s monthly Birth Information Update.
And if you’re a midwife or other birth worker who enjoys unpacking research, seeing what’s behind the headlines and sharing wisdom with like-minded others, come and join Sara and colleagues from all over the world in one of our online courses!